The list and the letter
You’ve seen the post: Richmond lands on another national ranking, the Greater Richmond Partnership shares it, and within the hour it’s in your feed with a few dozen likes from people who own businesses here. You’ve probably shared one yourself. It’s a good feeling to have built something in a city other people are starting to notice.
Months later, a different envelope shows up. The renewal letter. The number in it is higher than the owner expected, the window to respond is shorter than they’d like, and the two things that would’ve helped most, time and a sense of what else was out there, are both gone. They thought they had time. The landlord had more information than they did, and had been reading the same lists.
What the lists actually say
Three of them matter for a lease conversation, and the movement matters more than any single number.
- Site Selection magazine surveys site consultants each year on which cities they favor for corporate headquarters projects. Richmond tied for eighth in the 2024 survey, was named just outside the top five in 2025, and tied for fifth in January 2026.
- LinkedIn’s 2026 Cities on the Rise, which covers mid-size metros with fewer than 2.5 million LinkedIn members, put Richmond at #2. A year earlier it was #13.
- Twelve Greater Richmond companies made the 2026 Fortune 1000, six of them in the Fortune 500. That’s a count, not a ranking, but it’s the kind of count that site consultants and investors notice.
Virginia also ranked #3 in CNBC’s 2026 Top States for Business, which says something about the state and less about Richmond specifically.
A caution on cause and effect: rankings don’t set rents. Nobody at a magazine decides what your landlord asks for. What the lists do is signal demand, and demand is what landlords price.
Who else is reading
Landlords, local investors and out-of-town buyers evaluating Richmond for the first time read these lists too. The rankings you share on LinkedIn show up in the same market reports those people read. Cushman & Wakefield | Thalhimer’s Q2 2026 Richmond market infographic opens with the Site Selection #5 ranking, which is a normal thing for a brokerage to do. It’s the market’s best news.
Put yourself in the owner’s chair. If you owned a building in a city that outsiders increasingly want to be in, and you knew the next tenant was easier to find than it was five years ago, would you give much on rent? Would you offer the same free months or build-out allowance you offered in 2021? Probably not, and nobody would call that unreasonable. It’s the same math every business owner runs when demand for what they have goes up.
The numbers back up the mood. CoStar data puts the market value of Richmond retail buildings at $203 per square foot in 2026, up from $166 in 2021, a 22% increase. That’s the backdrop a retail landlord brings to your renewal.
What the numbers show
Start with retail, because that’s where most restaurant and storefront tenants sit and where the data is clearest. One note first: these retail figures are quoted triple net (NNN), so the base rent numbers below don’t include the tenant’s share of the property’s taxes, insurance and maintenance. Those come on top, as the NNN charges. Everything here is CoStar data, market asking rent per square foot per year and vacancy rate, Q4 of each year, with 2026 meaning 2026 to date.
| Submarket | 2021 rent/SF | 2026 rent/SF | Change | 2021 vacancy | 2026 vacancy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Short Pump | $29.13 | $36.38 | +25% | 8.0% | 1.2% |
| Broad St Corridor | $18.87 | $23.17 | +23% | 3.2% | 3.9% |
| Near West End | $20.68 | $24.81 | +20% | 3.2% | 3.1% |
Rents up 20% to 25% in five years. Vacancy at or under 4% in all three, and in Short Pump it fell from 8% to just over 1%.
A hypothetical 2,000 square foot Short Pump storefront that signed at 2021 asking rents and renews at today’s would pay about $7.25 more per square foot, roughly $1,208 more per month, or about $72,500 more across a five-year term. The same hypothetical space on the Broad Street corridor: about $717 more per month, about $43,000 over five years. In the Near West End, about $688 a month and $41,300 over the term. Those are base rent figures only. The NNN charges move on their own schedule.
Then the forward view. CoStar’s forecast has retail rents in Short Pump, the Broad Street corridor and the Near West End rising another 3% to 4% a year, with vacancy holding near or below 3%. On the same hypothetical 2,000 square feet, CoStar’s numbers put a Short Pump tenant renewing in 2028 at about $435 more per month than one renewing now, and a Near West End tenant at about $292 more. That’s CoStar’s forecast, not ours, and forecasts miss. The direction, though, has been consistent for five years.
The vacancy numbers matter more than the rent numbers. Your leverage in any renewal comes from one thing: having somewhere else to go. At 1% to 4% vacancy, the somewhere else barely exists. The few spaces that do come open get taken fast, sometimes before the general public ever knows they’re available. Finding a real alternative in these submarkets takes months, and months are exactly what the tenant who waits for the letter doesn’t have.
Where tenants still have leverage
Office is a different market, downtown retail is too, and tenants in both have more room to negotiate right now than retail tenants do.
These office figures are quoted full service, meaning the landlord’s operating costs are built into the rent. What’s included, utilities especially, varies lease to lease. Because the basis is different, don’t compare these to the retail figures. Compare office to itself. From 2021 to 2026, CoStar data has CBD asking rents moving from $21.84 to $25.16 per square foot, Monroe Ward from $17.51 to $20.61, Glenside/Broad Street from $22.59 to $24.96, and North Broad from $21.65 to $24.90. Rents rose about 2.5% to 4% a year from 2021 through 2025. Over the last 12 months, growth slowed to 2.1% in the CBD, 1.2% in North Broad, 1.0% in Glenside/Broad Street and 0.3% in Monroe Ward. Vacancy is higher than in 2021 in every one of them: 9.4% in the CBD, 8.6% in Monroe Ward, 10.5% in North Broad, and 14.7% in Glenside/Broad Street.
Downtown retail is in the same spot. Asking rents went from $16.21 to $18.99, the smallest increase of any retail submarket in the data, and vacancy went the other way, from 10.6% to 16.2%, the highest of any submarket the highest of any submarket we looked at.
What does that mean if you’re an office tenant or a downtown storefront? In a submarket where nearly 15% of office space sits empty, a landlord needs you more than a Short Pump landlord does. You can ask for things: a lower annual escalation, more free rent, a tenant improvement allowance, a termination option, a shorter term. Whether you get them depends on the building, the owner and how the conversation is run. Starting early is how you run it well.
We don’t know when office conditions turn. The CoStar data we’re working from doesn’t include an office forecast, and we’re not going to invent one. We do know that leverage is easiest to use while you have it and hardest to recover once a renewal notice has set the clock.
The 12 to 18 month calendar
Pull out your lease this week and find the renewal option. In Richmond commercial leases, the notice deadline commonly falls 6, 9 or 12 months before the lease ends, and the only way to know which one applies to you is to read your own. Write the date down. Miss it, and you could lose the option to renew on the lease’s terms. Your attorney reads what your specific lease says. We’re describing a pattern, not giving legal advice.
Now work backward from that date.
- About 6 months before the deadline: decide whether staying is the plan and price real alternatives.
- 3 to 6 months before: tour spaces and start the renewal conversation with options in hand.
- At the deadline: exercise the option or don’t, on purpose.
If a move is likely, start earlier, because finding space and build-out can take most of a year.
That order isn’t an accident. Knowing your alternatives is what gives a renewal conversation any weight. A landlord can tell the difference between a tenant who has toured three spaces and a tenant who is hoping the number comes in low. We wrote more about running that conversation in Lease Renewal Is a Negotiation, Not a Formality and, if you’re leaning toward a move, in Before You Start Looking for Space, Read This.
We’ve seen this pattern often enough that we’re building a process around it. Our transaction coordinator is setting up renewal dates and notice deadlines for the tenants we work with, so the timeline above starts on our calendar, not when the renewal letter arrives. From there, we find out what comparable spaces are leasing for, tour the real alternatives with you, and handle the renewal conversation with your landlord from your side of the table. If you’re going to bring in a broker, do it before your first call to the landlord. If that conversation has already started, tell the landlord who’s representing you as soon as you hire someone.
Plan for it
Richmond’s doing well, and it earned the lists. The tenant who plans for that negotiates a different lease than the one who finds out from the renewal letter.